elevate techConsulting Group

Independent ERP and system selection

What does an ERP implementation really cost beyond the quote?

An ERP implementation costs more than the quote because the quote covers the vendor's software and services, not your side of the project. The usual gaps are data cleanup and migration, integrations, training, backfilling your own people's time, customization, reporting, a second phase and ongoing support. Ask about each one in writing before you sign.

None of this means the vendor is hiding something. A quote answers the question "what will we deliver?" It does not answer "what will this cost the company?" Those are different questions, and the second one is yours to answer. This article lists the items to price. For the questions to put to the vendor, see what to ask an ERP vendor before you sign. The wider process is on our ERP selection page.

What are the hidden costs of ERP?

The hidden costs of ERP are data cleanup and migration, integrations, training, your own people's time, customization, reporting, a second phase and ongoing support. The quote is only part of the cost because a quote is a sales document. It is organized around what the vendor sells: licenses or subscriptions, a block of implementation hours, perhaps some training days. Your company's real cost also includes everything the vendor assumes you will supply. The sections below follow the order in which owners usually get surprised.

What does data cleanup and migration cost?

The software does not fix your data. It moves it. If your customer list has duplicates, your item records have three naming conventions, and your vendor terms live in a spreadsheet, the new system inherits all of it unless someone cleans it first.

Cleanup takes people who know the data, which means your people. Ask who does it, how many test loads the vendor includes, and what happens when a trial load fails. Decide how much history to bring across. Moving everything is expensive. Moving too little leaves staff logging into two systems for a year.

What do integrations cost?

Few companies run on a single system. Your ERP will need to talk to the storefront, the warehouse tools, payroll, the CRM, a bank feed, a shipping service. Each connection is a small project with its own build, testing and upkeep. A vendor may list "standard connectors" that cover some of these and leave others as custom work.

Ask for a list of every system the new ERP must connect to, and for each one: who builds it, who tests it, who fixes it when it breaks. A connection that works at go-live and nobody owns afterward is a future outage.

What does training really involve?

Vendor training usually covers how the software works. It rarely covers how your company will work in it. People need to learn the new process, not just the new screens, and that takes repetition on your data. Budget for time in the classroom, time practicing, and the weeks after go-live when output slows down while people find their feet.

What does it cost to backfill your own people?

This is the cost most often left off the budget. Your best finance, operations and warehouse people will be the ones who sit in design sessions, test processes and sign off. They are also the people who keep the business running now. Something has to give.

The options are overtime, temporary staff, contractors, or work that waits. Each has a price. Work that waits is the one that goes unmeasured and shows up later as late invoices, missed collections or a weaker month-end close. Ask the vendor for hours by role, then decide who covers those people's day jobs.

Want to know what your current systems will make harder before you spend on a new one?

Take the Systems Check

What does customization cost?

Customization is any change to how the software behaves out of the box. Some is necessary. Much of it is a company carrying an old habit into a new system. Every customization has a build cost, a testing cost, and a cost each time the vendor releases an update that has to be checked against it.

Ask for every customization to be listed with a reason. A useful test: if the answer to "why do we need this?" is "because that is how we have always done it," look at the process first. In our experience the problem is often the process, not the software.

What does reporting cost?

Owners buy an ERP to see the business more clearly. Reports are how that happens, and they are frequently treated as an afterthought. The standard reports that ship with the product may not match the ones your board, lender or private equity sponsor expects. Ask which reports are included, which must be built, and who builds them. Write down the ten reports you cannot run the business without, and ask the vendor to show each one on your data.

Is there a second phase?

Most projects have one, whether the plan admits it or not. A first phase gets the core finance and order processes live. The things that were deferred, such as extra locations, advanced inventory features, a customer portal or deeper reporting, come next. If the quote prices only phase one, ask for a rough shape and range of phase two so the board sees the whole commitment, not the first installment.

The wireless infrastructure services company in our first ERP and CRM case study cut $43,500 from the first-phase statement of work before signature, with the scope unchanged. Trimming scope is a sound way to control cost, but it works best when the deferred items are written down and owned, not forgotten.

What does ongoing support cost?

After go-live, someone has to keep the system healthy: apply updates, add users, fix problems, adjust reports, retrain new hires. That can be the vendor, a partner, an internal administrator or a mix. Ask what is included in the annual fee, what response times mean in practice, and what the price increase terms are at renewal. Decide who inside the company owns the system. A system nobody owns drifts.

What happens to cost at renewal?

Subscription and support prices usually change at renewal, and the contract decides how. Look for the renewal term, the notice period, any cap on annual increases, and whether a minimum number of users or a minimum spend carries forward. A price that was fixed for the first term may be open to a larger increase after it, and a missed notice date can renew you automatically.

Put the renewal date in the calendar the day you sign. Ask the vendor now for the price-increase terms in writing, and compare them with what you actually use, not what you bought. If you added users, entities or locations during the term, expect the renewal to reflect them. Renewal is also your next chance to renegotiate, so go in with usage numbers.

How much should I budget on top of the quote?

There is no honest percentage we can give you without seeing your data, your systems and your people, so be wary of anyone who offers one. Build the number from the worksheet below instead. Price each line item the quote excludes, assign your own team's time by role, and add a separate contingency that someone other than the project manager controls.

Then size the contingency to your situation. Messier data, more systems to connect and a thinner internal team all argue for more. Ask your advisor to challenge the budget against projects like yours, and ask the board to approve the total, not the vendor's quote. If the total looks too large, cut scope in writing and list what you deferred, rather than quietly shrinking the contingency.

The worksheet: line items to ask about

Use this table when you compare quotes. For each vendor, mark every row as included, excluded or unclear, then add a cost or an owner. We have deliberately left the amounts blank. They depend on your size, your data and the vendor.

Line itemWhat to askIncluded / excluded / unclearWho pays and who does it
Software or subscriptionPriced by user, module, entity or location?
Implementation servicesFixed price or hours? Who is on the team?
Data cleanupWho cleans, and to what standard?
Data migrationHow many test loads? How much history?
IntegrationsWhich systems, built by whom, kept by whom?
TrainingHow many sessions, for whom, on our data?
Backfill for your staffHours by role per week, covered how?
CustomizationEach change listed with its reason
ReportingWhich of our must-have reports ship as standard?
Phase twoWhat is deferred, and what is its rough range?
Support and renewalWhat does the annual fee cover? Price terms?
ContingencyWho holds it, who can release it?

How do you use the worksheet?

Fill in one column per vendor before you pick a finalist. Where the answer is "unclear," that is a question to send back. Where a cost sits on your side, assign a person. Then add up your own commitments as well as the vendor's, because the board should approve the total, not the quote.

If you are earlier in the process, how to choose an ERP walks through the steps in order.

Common questions

Why do ERP projects cost more than the quote?

A quote prices the vendor's software and services. It rarely prices your own team's time, data cleanup, integrations to systems you already run, or the second phase that most projects need. Those costs are real but sit outside the document you signed.

Which hidden cost do owners most often miss?

In our experience it is the time of your own people. They must test, decide, clean data and learn the system while still running the business. That time is paid for in overtime, temporary help or work left undone.

Should you add a contingency to the budget?

Yes. Hold a contingency that is separate from the quote, and decide in advance who can release it. The right size depends on how clean your data is and how many systems must connect, so ask your advisor to size it from your own situation.

How do you compare quotes from different vendors fairly?

Put every vendor's quote into the same worksheet of line items. Mark each as included, excluded or unclear. The cheapest quote is often the one with the most items marked excluded.

Not sure where to start?

Take a free three-minute score. If a conversation makes sense, it will offer one.